Education Ministers reform list: welcome, with questions!
Andy Mison, President and Executive Director, Australian Secondary Principals’ Association

Education ministers agreed a substantial suite of reforms on 2 November. Much of it is sensible and welcome, on the face of it. I have questions though, and hopefully we get the chance to discuss the planning and implementation schedule, how it all fits with the already busy Better and Fairer Schools Agreement reform agenda, and the unresolved issues of workforce sustainability, before schools have to wade through it on the job.
There are two large state elections looming and a federal poll not far behind, any time from August 2027. Reforms announced now will presumably be implemented across those electoral cycles, so the plan needs to work whatever the results. I support the positive intent of our ministers, and I am mindful of the cumulative impact on the professional work teachers and school leaders are doing every day. We must test with them whether they have capacity and, if so, what the most practical plan is to design and implement change. Whatever we do should be done sustainably, for the right reasons: learning progress and wellbeing.
Let's start with what we welcome. Ministers agreed that technology in schools should be deployed purposefully and in the service of learning and wellbeing, and that it should be restricted where it fails that test. Principals have managed this kind of balance for years, mostly school by school with little national guidance. They would largely accept that some limits are warranted. A national principle, and a working group or ‘taskforce’ that includes principal associations, should help achieve a more consistent approach.
However, limits should be set as straightforward guidelines that schools apply according to their situation. Differentiation and context are key. A Year 7 student learning to manage a device for the first time, a Year 12 student preparing for an exam sat on screen, and a student taking a subject online need different settings. At the same time, more links to well-meaning online resource hubs, posters and factsheets, arriving with nine other attachments in the inbox, will not help much.
Research led by Macquarie University for the NSW Department of Education suggests few high school leaders believe students can regulate their own technology use during learning. The researchers found the greatest room for improvement lies in the conditions around screen use: clearer shared expectations between school and home, explicit teaching of self-regulation as students move into high school, reliable technical support, and guidance for families and on the use of AI. Much unstructured screen use happens at home. Tackling that takes political courage and sensitivity. Limits at school will help, but they won’t fix everything.
Generative AI is the trickier problem that schools are working on. Most NSW principals in the Macquarie Uni survey were concerned about AI malpractice in assessment at least some of the time, and many have already moved senior assessment tasks under teacher supervision. Restricting AI in secondary assessment will protect integrity. Students also need to learn when, how, and why to use these tools, and to understand their limits, biases, and risks. Learning in the digital world was Australia's strongest PISA 2025 result, and we should build on it. That might need professional learning for teachers with the time to do it properly.
This is why the prospective taskforce needs practitioners at the table from the outset. Principals and teachers know where technology adds value in their subjects and communities, where blanket limits would add workload or widen inequity, and what support families need. The NSW principals who answered the survey asked for authentic collaboration on guidelines that allow for context. Guidance designed with the profession is far more likely to work in classrooms.
The attention to civics is welcome. Civic knowledge among students is at its lowest point since testing began in 2004. A democracy depends on young people who understand how it works and take part in it. Students also learn democracy by practising it. At a school I led our student representatives ran a democracy in action program with the Australian Electoral Commission that engaged the entire school community very effectively. It involved all students in an authentic election process, complete with a democracy sausage after voting. Civics is already mandatory in Years 7 and 8, so before adding core content to a crowded Years 9 and 10 curriculum, it is worth considering what would need to go to make way for it and whether other approaches could meet the same intent.
The curriculum changes to address antisemitism, and the wider commitment to social cohesion, respond to a real and serious need in our community. Our public schools are already inclusive, welcoming learning environments where staff work hard to make sure everyone is respectful of difference and able to learn. Schools will do this work best when it builds on the practice already in place and gives leaders room to apply it in their own community context.
I also welcome the workforce conditions ministers attached to the announcements. I hope to see them prioritised in practice, through implementation planning that includes school leaders as co-designers. The return to handwritten Year 5 NAPLAN writing is subject to advice on feasibility, cost and workload. The civics proposal is subject to identifying content to remove and evaluating the effect on teacher workload. That’s the right discipline, and it should apply to the whole package.
The workload is cumulative, on top of an already big job. Between 2027 and 2029, secondary schools are likely to implement revised curriculum on antisemitism and civil discourse, possible core civics in Years 9 and 10, new limits on screens and on generative AI in assessment, possible changes to NAPLAN in Years 7 and 9, a new respectful relationships workplan, and the reforms already underway through the Better and Fairer Schools Agreements. Each change may be reasonable. Together they are a large change agenda for a stretched workforce. I ask ministers to work with us to develop an implementation schedule showing what impacts schools, when, and with what support.
There are also some silences in the communique.
The first, and largest, is disadvantage. The package is framed around declining results, but the data warrants a closer look. Across 25 years of national and international testing, sustained decline is clearest in PISA, while other measures show a more mixed picture. What the data show consistently is a gap between advantaged and disadvantaged students that widens through schooling and concentrates in particular schools. Ministers agreed a shared understanding of equity, to be published, and in February agreed to make equity a foundational consideration in the new Australian Teaching and Learning Commission. I look forward to seeing how that understanding addresses the concentration of disadvantage, and how it shapes resourcing as well as reform design. Device limits, for example, will affect students differently depending on what they have at home.
The second is accountability. The digital detox will be implemented by states, territories and sectors. Public schools already report against the conditions of the Better and Fairer Schools Agreements. In NSW, 81% of secondary principals surveyed were concerned that new screen guidelines would not apply to non-government schools. How will the community know these new commitments are applied consistently in every school that receives public funding?
The third is measurement. Changing how students sit the NAPLAN writing test will likely influence school priorities, and young people do need to write both by hand and with technology. What we measure is more important. NAPLAN is a narrow instrument, but has gradually come to dominate reform agendas. If the aim of these reforms is improved learning outcomes, the new Commission should start with scope to help systems measure the breadth of what students know and can do, including post-school outcomes built from equally valued vocational and academic pathways, engagement, agency, and the life competencies that are just as vital as the content they learn at school.
The fourth, once again, is sustainability. The communique says a good deal about what teachers and school leaders will do and little about the conditions in which they will do it. The progress of the good work underway on teacher and principal wellbeing and workplace safety deserves a central place on ministers' ongoing agenda. I hope this becomes a priority through the upcoming elections.
The fifth is the Australian Teaching and Learning Commission itself. Bringing ACARA, AITSL, AERO and ESA together could be an opportunity to strengthen national support for schools. Ministers have said the detailed arrangements will be worked through over the coming months with the agencies and other stakeholders. Teachers and school leaders should be among them from the start, with a formal role in the design work and time to contribute before legislation is drafted. A body built to support the profession will be stronger if the profession helps shape it.
Principals want these reforms to succeed. The surest way to achieve that is to plan implementation with the people who will carry it out. ASPA will keep raising these questions with ministers and their departments, and we offer our members' experience to help get the details right.





A useful scholarship guide should cover the questions students commonly ask during registration and after submission. Information about eligibility, application correction, verification, and payment processing can help applicants understand the complete procedure. Students should also save their application reference numbers. Such practical knowledge can make the process less stressful for first-time applicants. e kalyan Jharkhand